Wally's Lures Wooden Pencil Poppers

Prepare to light up the surface bite with Wally’s Wooden Pencil Poppers, built from highly buoyant western red cedar for unmatched performance. These lures are handcrafted to deliver long, accurate casts and effortless topwater action that draws strikes from aggressive predators.

Efficient Action with Minimal Effort

The Pencil Poppers are designed to walk and splash with minimal rod movement, making them easy to work for long sessions. Their buoyancy and shape create a lively commotion that mimics distressed baitfish, triggering explosive surface strikes.

Built for Serious Saltwater Anglers

Available in the proven 3 oz size, these plugs are perfectly suited for striped bass, bluefish, and other powerful saltwater gamefish. Their rugged cedar construction and durable finishes stand up to repeated abuse from toothy predators and tough fishing conditions.

A Wide Range of Productive Colors

From mackerel patterns to parrot, bunker, and classic blue-and-white finishes, Wally’s offers a variety of colorways to match baitfish and conditions. Whether fishing clear daylight or low-light surf, there’s a pattern designed to keep you connected to the bite.

Free Standard Shipping on Orders of $100

Orders of $100 or more will receive free standard shipping (3-5 business days) within the Continental US (Gift cards excluded). Your order must ship in a single box and have a dimensional weight of no greater 10 lbs. Many fishing rods and other long items that have a shipping dimension of over 60" do not qualify for free shipping. See individual item for details.

Cash Returns

We do not do cash refunds! All refunds must be put on a credit card.

Credit Card & Debit Card Returns - In-Store

You have 5 days from the date of purchase to return an item for a refund. An item returned from 6 days to 30 days from the purchase date is eligible for a store credit. Item must be in brand new condition, unused, in its original packaging, and accompanied by a valid receipt. Rods must have original tags. If you do not have a receipt you will be given store credit. It is your responsibility to ask for a receipt at time of purchase.

Credit Card & Debit Card Returns - Online

You have 14 days from the date of purchase to return an item for a refund on a purchase made with a credit card or debit card online. All refunds will be issued to the original method of payment. An item returned from 15 days to 30 days from the purchase date is eligible for a store credit. Item must be in brand new condition, unused, in its original packaging, and accompanied by a valid receipt. Rods must have original tags. If you do not have a receipt you will be given store credit. It is your responsibility to ask for a receipt at time of purchase!

Please visit the Returns Center to process a return.